12 Answers to Money Questions From Your Grandchildren

3. Should I leave money in my will to my grandchild?   

In a word: Maybe. 

Rand says his clients are generally split on this one. Many of his clients have adult children in their 50s and 60s who are already financially secure. Even though their adult children don’t really need the money, they still feel like they’re “supposed” to leave their money to them — and not to their grandchildren. “I encourage clients to have conversations with their children about this,” says Rand.

For a grandchild who is a minor, suggests Whitty, have the funds go into a Uniform Transfers to Minors Act (UTMA) account with a parent, aunt or uncle as custodian so that no guardianship is required.

4. Should I offer to help pay for my grandchild’s car?

In a word: Iffy. 

“The first thing to consider is, what’s your goal in giving them this gift,” says Rand. In other words, find out what your grandchild’s specific plans are for the car. If it’s to drive to work — or to college classes — that’s a reasonable argument to help them get a car, he says.

You probably should check in with your own children (the grandchild’s parents) first, advises Kraus. Some parents want to teach their kids about having a work ethic and might be upset with a surprise “handout” from grandparents for a new car, he says.

5. What should I get my grandchild for college graduation?

In a word: Cash. 

College graduation is a turning point for many young adults, so the best gift is often something that helps them move up to the next step, says Rand. That can be anything from help with a down payment on a new house to a down payment on a new car, he says.

Practical cash gifts that help your grandchild achieve his or her dream can be huge, says Catherine Valega, a certified financial planner in Winchester, Massachusetts. That can mean anything from helping to pay off student loans to covering the grandchild’s moving expenses if they have to move for a new job, she says.

6. What are the best holiday or birthday gifts for my grandchild?

In a word: 529. 

Over the long run, no gift will likely leave more lifetime impact than regular contributions to your grandkid’s 529 plan, says Rand. He has three daughters who are each fully aware that for their birthdays and for Christmas, their grandmother contributes money to their 529 college accounts.

He keeps separate accounts for each child — and he occasionally reviews the balance with each of them so they can see how their own account is growing. At the same time, their grandmother typically gives them small gifts for these occasions as well, but the bulk of her gift giving is to help make certain all three of her granddaughters get to college.

7. Should I check with my children before giving cash gifts to my grandkids?

In a word: Yes.

The best parents are always working on ways to teach good spending habits to their kids, and large cash gifts from grandparents to their grandkids can totally disrupt that, advises Rand.

Some parents, says Kraus, also discourage direct cash gifts from grandparents to grandkids out of concern that the money might actually be used to purchase things that rarely get the parental seal of approval: drugs or alcohol.

8. What if my grandchild asks me for money?

In a word: Teach.  

If a grandchild asks you for money, think of it as a unique opportunity to teach them a good lesson about money, says Nadine Burns, a certified financial planner in Ann Arbor, Michigan. “Determine if it’s a need or a want, and have a discussion with them about how you can — or can’t — help them solve the problem,” she says.

If the reason is a good one — perhaps they need help buying a car for a new job they just got — that’s when you should also pull the parents into the discussion, she says.

9. What if my grandkid doesn’t come to me for money, but I see they need it?

In a word: Talk.  

First, talk to the parents and check that it’s OK to make the offer, says Kraus.  Next, make 100 percent certain it won’t enable future poor spending habits.  For example, if you help to pay off their credit card debt, he asks, what lesson have they learned? That said, if you’ve helped them through a one-time emergency — such as an unexpected medical expense — a small financial gesture from grandparents “can become a great life change,” he says.

10. Do I speak out if I see my grandkid wasting money?

In a word: Nope.

“One generation’s frivolous spending could be another generation’s basic lifestyle,” says Kraus.​

11. Should I invest in my grandchild’s business venture?

In a word: No. 

Investing in any business can be risky, but when it’s a family member, it could harm the relationship if things go bad. “Unless you can afford to lose your investment and/or have vast experience in small business investing, I would not suggest investing in a grandchild’s business,” says Kraus. “Most small businesses go under in just a few years.” ​

12. Should I cosign a loan for them?

In a word: Maybe. 

Cosigning a loan can allow future generations to get money at a much lower interest rate, but if you cosign, you’re liable, warns Kraus. “Things go wrong even with the best plans and intentions. Make sure you can afford to pay the loan if your grandchild cannot,” he says.